6 Comments

  1. Ron Koprowski says:

    Clear and concise – love your style. Your topics are great for coming back to basics and the value of mastering them.
    11 of us are in a great Latin class at our OLLI (Osher Lifelong Learning Institute) at Furman University. The class is currently translating and discussing Pliny’s and Trajan’s letters. Young Pliny is a master at confusing modern readers with bizarre word order and complex grammar.
    Your emails anchor my grammar foundations before I take on Young Pliny.

    1. Hi Ron, I am glad to hear that my posts are helping you out with Pliny. Your class sounds like a lot of fun! I read Pliny’s letter on the eruption of Vesuvius with my Latin students a few years ago and we enjoyed it immensely 🙂

  2. I LOVE the way you explain things and am so grateful. I was really confused by this sentence in Familia Romana: “Pueri saccos plenos QUI a servis portantur vident et interrogant” and you cleared it up for me. Thanks!

    1. Hi Meggan, I’m glad my post helped you out with this sentence. Understanding which case of the relative pronoun is used – and why – is tricky at first, but it sounds like you are making good progress!

  3. Bjørn Vigeland says:

    Why «Lapidem» (accusativus) and not «Lapis» (nominativus) in following passage from the Vulgata Bible. As far as I can see the stone is the subject of “factus est”:
    Matt., 21:42 Dicit illis Iesus: Numquam legistis in Scripturis: Lapidem, quem reprobaverunt ædificantes, hic factus est in caput anguli. A Domino factum est istud, et est mirabile in oculis nostris:

    1. Hi Bjørn, you are absolutely right that we would expect the nominative form lapis here (since it is the subject of factus est. This is likely an example of “attraction”, that is, when the antecedent of a relative pronoun acquires the same case as the relative pronoun. Since quem is in the accusative (as the direct object of reprobaverunt), lapis becomes lapidem by attraction.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I accept the Privacy Policy