2 Comments

  1. Stephen Peplow says:

    I recall at school learning that the size of the island of Rhodes was important in determining whether to use in or on. If the place you were describing was smaller than Rhodes then you use in and vice-versa. Have I got that right? It has been a while. Thank you

    1. Hi Stephen, the island of Rhodes is significant in Latin because it is the largest island that uses the locative case to express location (instead of using *in* + the ablative). So it would not surprise me if Rhodes divided islands in English usage, too. I believe that islands larger than Rhodes would use *in*, while Rhodes and smaller would use *on.*

      You can read more about the locative/ablative distinction here: https://booksnbackpacks.com/latin-locative-case/#what-latin-nouns-have-the-locative-case.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I accept the Privacy Policy